FC Cincinnati came into Thursday’s match against Chivas in need of scoring four more goals in regulation to move on to the Knockout Round. However, Head Coach Pat Noonan chose to rest his starters and play the reserves, giving the young players a chance.
Noonan said the decision came down to balancing performance and recovery across the roster. “A lot of guys needed a little bit of a rest,” he said. “We had those conversations, and for the most part, the guys did a good job with the opportunity.”
FCC ultimately fell 2-1, with goals from Efraín Álvarez and Armando González lifting Chivas, while Andrés Dávila marked his FCC debut with a goal just minutes after subbing in.
First Half
Around 24 minutes into the match, Efraín Álvarez of Chivas scored on a PK after a foul was called inside the box on FCC.
It was 1-0 heading into halftime, after the FCC reserves struggled to keep up with Chivas all half.
“We conceded on a penalty and then on a throw-in; those are the parts we can do better,” Noonan said. “We can’t let a guy get into a position to put in a cross that easily. Outside of those moments, I thought we did a reasonable job in transitions.”
Second Half
Chivas later extended their lead to 2-0 on a major defensive lapse from FCC, as Armando González found the back of the net in the 57th minute.
But FCC answered quickly. Directly after being subbed into the match, Andrés Dávila tapped a pass home to trim the deficit to 2-1 around the 67-minute mark.
“Dávila showed he can be effective, how he creates separation, and delivers the right pass at the right time,” said Noonan. “He was strong and impactful in the attack; you could see he was involved in some of our better moments. Some of his actions in the final third were among our best of the night.”
Despite a late surge from FCC, Chivas hung on for a 2-1 victory.
“I thought we lacked a bit of creativity and movement off the ball,” Noonan reflected. “The game was too slow at times, and we didn’t offer enough options. As the game progressed, it improved, maybe that was personnel, maybe just how the game unfolded.”
With the result ending their tournament run, Noonan said the club still got value out of the group stage.
“We knew the format and the challenges going in,” he said. “It’s a difficult way to advance, but we understood that. Even though the results didn’t go our way, we positioned ourselves to get something out of it.”
He noted that individual performances and developmental moments were key takeaways, especially for FCC’s younger players.
“You want these guys in real scenarios where they have to work together and make decisions,” said Noonan. “That’s how they grow. There were good performances and some glimpses from the young guys that show there’s something to build on. There was enough progress for us to keep focusing on the bigger picture.”
One standout was Stiven Jimenez, who played the full 90 minutes after a substitute appearance against Juárez.
“Stiven’s been simple and effective on the ball,” Noonan said. “His understanding of how his role shifts depending on the front three and our pressing structure is still evolving, but he’s making strides. You have to trust guys in certain moments, and he’s earning that.”
Veteran leadership also helped hold things together.
“There was good communication and leadership from the experienced guys,” said Noonan. “It wasn’t just about the result tonight; it was about seeing what we could take away from it heading back into the regular season.”
FC Cincinnati now shifts its focus back to league play and will resume MLS action on Sunday, hosting Charlotte FC at 6:00 PM ET in TQL Stadium.
“We’ll take the lessons from this tournament and shift our focus back to the league,” Noonan said. “There’s progress and that’s what we keep building on.”
Author
